Archdeacon Insurance Agency
2233 Nesconset Hwy Suite 202, Lake Grove
4.9 56 reviews
-
K Fallon ★★★★★ 7 months ago
Fantastic! Amazing service. Helped us navigate many different insurance policies findings the best for our needs. -
Nathanael Guerra ★★★★★ 7 months ago
I found myself in a bit of a problem with a previous home insurance company and after contacting several other insurance agencies, Sheri at The Archdeacon Agency was by far the most helpful. She found a new company for me at a good price … More and cancelled my old policy. I will recommend The Archdeacon Agency to everyone I know. -
Christine ★★★★★ a year ago
Sheri at the Archdeacon Agency goes above and beyond to help you find the policies that are not only best for your needs, but also save you money. She is compassionate, understanding, caring, patient and knowledgeable, which are all qualities … More that are helpful and appreciated when you are trying to find what works best for everyone in your family.What I will always be grateful to Sheri for is that even though I was not able to switch to her agency at the time my policies were up for renewal due to complicating circumstances she understood and reassured me that all the time she spent with me was still worth it because it allowed me to see that there were other more reasonable and better options out there for me when I am ready to renew next year.Thankfully my son’s policy is with her and I look forward to working with her to try to find a better option for him when his policy is up for renewal and to get the rest of my families polices transferred over to her agency when my policies are up for renewal again this year.Thank you Sheri for being you and for all of your time, dedication and understanding. It is a pleasure to work with you and I truly appreciate all of the time and effort that you spent with me a few months back when I was going through a very stressful time.It is a pleasure to recommend you and your agency to others and to let them know how above and beyond you went to help me find comparable policies for my home and auto at such a significant savings! -
Debbie Rosengard ★★★★★ a year ago
Sheri at Arch Deacon Agency is truly incredible! She is professional, attentive, and goes above and beyond to ensure everything is seamless. Her expertise and dedication makes all the difference, and I couldn’t be more grateful. If you’re … More looking for someone who genuinely cares and delivers exceptional service, Sheri is the one. Highly recommend! -
Michelle P ★★★★★ a year ago
The Archdeacon Agency was highly recommended and did not disappoint! They have gone above and beyond, Craig sat down and answered all my questions, went over my auto, homeowners and umbrella policies. Explained many things I was not aware … More … More -
Edward Blair ★★★★★ a year ago
The service at Archdeacon is top-notch. Response to client needs and requests is always prompt, and the information and help dispensed satify all client questions. My personal experience has shown that Ms. Bender is a caring individual … More who will go out of her way to assist people in any way she can. -
Alycia Bender ★★★★★ a year ago
An insurance agency that truly cares about your best options & well-being. In an industry that can be money hungry & careless, it’s so important to work with people that actually care as opposed to just pushing papers. Communication … More & customer service is top priority!! -
Sunshine Okubo ★★★★★ a year ago
Wow!! I am so happy my paths crossed with Sheri and this agency! Everyone there is friendly and very knowledgeable! They switched my car, home insurance policy and they added ins for my business….and I still saved over $400’s a year!!! … More So grateful!! Thank you again!!! -
Jenna Biggs ★★★★★ a year ago
I recently had an excellent experience with The Archdeacon Agency Inc. Their customer service was top-notch—every representative was knowledgeable, friendly, and attentive to my needs. They took the time to thoroughly explain my policy … More options and helped me find the best coverage for my situation. The entire process was smooth and efficient, and I appreciate their transparency and professionalism. Highly recommend them for anyone seeking reliable and personalized insurance services! -
Mike Lanning ★★★★★ a year ago
Craig was incredibly kind, knowledgeable, and provided a truly wonderful experience all-around. He was able to get me a significantly cheaper rate for my car insurance, and he handled everything to make my transition between companies … More as seamless and easy as possible. I would highly recommend both him and The Archdeacon Agency to anyone. Thank you so much! -
sandra ianniello ★★★★★ 2 years ago
I cannot rave enough about the simplicity of working with Archdeacon! I needed to get affordable car insurance fast to process paperwork for my new car. Sheri and Craig made the process SO easy. They gave me a call same day and had quotes … More … More -
James Rapaccioli ★★★★★ 2 years ago
Archdeacon has been so helpful to myself and my family over the years. They are readily and happily available to their customers and work hard to get us the best rates for EVERY type of insurance. I love being able to call someone from … More the … More -
Tina Marie ★★★★★ 2 years ago
On short notice I was being dropped by my old insurance carrier who I'd been with since I started driving. I reached out to both Craig and Alycia, and they made what I thought would be a huge headache extremely simple and quick. In … More just a … More -
Diane Porfido ★★★★★ 2 years ago
I have been insured through this agency for over 10 years. Sheri Bender has my homeowners, auto and umbrella policies. Sheri is my go to person for any type of insurance question, she is the most knowledgeable insurance agent I know of. … More … More -
Jeanine Facciponte ★★★★★ 2 years ago
We have worked with several agencies to find the best insurance quote and Archdeacon agency far exceeded them all. Jayden and the staff epitomize professionalism, work ethic and more importantly care for your insurance needs. They go above … More and beyond for their clients and we highly recommend them. -
Portia Gelormino ★★★★★ 2 years ago
As someone who used to be a licensed insurance agent with a Certified Insurance Service Representative designation, I can tell you that Craig and everyone at Archdeacon Agency are second to none when it comes to thorough coverage evaluation … More … More -
T C ★★★★★ 2 years ago
My experiences with Archdeacon have been most positive. Sheri approaches my needs with assurance and urgency. I’m so thankful to Sheri and the Archdeacon Agency and look forward to a continued partnership. -
victor desantis ★★★★★ 2 years ago
Archdeacon has gone above and beyond for our business. They always look for ways to get us the best rates. Sheri and Craig make the paperwork process so easy and are always available to answer any questions we have. -
Tom Blewitt ★★★★★ 2 years ago
Our Family has been with The Archdeacon Agency for about 40 years. A constant throughout that time has been the professionalism and strong customer service ethic exhibited by the team. I'm pleased to say that Jayden Ippolito is … … More More -
Alex Arciniega ★★★★★ 2 years ago
What more can I say than the five stars that are given, Craig not only showed professionalism but he was persistent in finding me the best coverage and prices for both my auto and renters policy’s. If you’re looking to get any type of insurance … More he does it all! -
Gerry Russo ★★★★★ 2 years ago
Ive been using Craig for the past year and i have nothing but good things to say about him. Any issues i have i can call him day or night and he handles it right away. I highly recommend using Craig and the archdeacon agency!! -
helen smith ★★★★★ 2 years ago
I have been with this agency for a few years. I work with Craig as much as possible. He knows my family and what we need to be sufficiently insured. I have great faith in Craig. -
jessica karp ★★★★★ 2 years ago
We could not be happier with using Craig at the Archdeacon Agency. His attention to detail, accuracy and professionalism are top notch! we would definitely recommend him. -
Virginia Annunziata ★★★★★ 2 years ago
Staff is very knowledgeable and friendly. Highly recommend The Archdeacon Agency for all insurance needs. -
Kareem K Kline ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig Bender is the best Insurance agent around! He shops for the best rates, and makes the process hassle free. When I first called, he got me more coverage, for less money. I’ve been with him for a little over a year now, and have 3 … … More More -
S R ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Sheri is very professional and knowledgeable. She worked hard to find me the best rates for home/auto/umbrella, resulting in savings of over $1000 compared with my previous insurance company. It’s a pleasure to deal with an agency that … More … More -
Katelyn Johnson ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig Bender is amazing! I knew Craig while living in NY and just recently moved to CA. Craig helped me get renter's insurance at my new place that was affordable and had great coverage. Very impressed by his services especially all … More the way across the country! I will definitely be recommending him to my friends and family. -
Carley P. Weinstein ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig Bender and Jayden Ippolito were so incredibly helpful throughout the entire process of my fiancee and I securing auto and renter's insurance. We were being ripped off by our previous auto insurance company, and Craig and Jayden … More saw to … More -
Tyler Panetta ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig is the man! When I was looking for Insurance on my new vehicle I reached out to Craig for a quote and he was honest and said that he had nothing competitive to the policy I have now. When I thought I was going to have to keep paying … More … More -
John Kelly ★★★★★ 3 years ago
The team at Archdeacon is great to work with, and a great resource that I have come to rely on. Craig has helped me find the proper coverage for both my personal and business needs. I highly recommend you give them a call the next time … More you are looking for insurance. -
mb b ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Sheri Bender worked very hard to find me the best insurance policies to meet my needs. She is very professional and extremely knowledgeable and makes sure everything is handled properly. I highly recommend Sheri for all your insurance needs. … More -
Sharon Wyman ★★★★★ 3 years ago
I have had the pleasure of working with Craig for the past year, he has always been so positive and a pleasure to work with. Craig makes it a point to always find me the best rates and quotes and we are so grateful to be one of his clients! … More -
Gail Sanderson ★★★★★ 3 years ago
I was referred to This agency through my boss who uses them for our business insurances. When I first called I was connected to Jayden who not only worked for several days (keeping me in the loop the entire time) to get my car insurance … More as … More -
Stephen Baker ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig was polite, professional and quick to respond back to any of my concerns and requests. I am thrilled to be working with someone who honestly has my company’s best interest in mind. Thanks again Craig!! -
Bryn Elliott ★★★★★ 3 years ago
I've had several dealings with The Archdeacon Agency and have found that everyone there is extremely knowledgeable, provides great service and they have very competitive rates. They've always made it easy for me. I highly recommend … More them. -
Anthony Mirabella ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig is the best! Gets everything I need done quick and efficient. Makes insurance super easy and saves money! -
Samuel Piro Jr ★★★★★ 3 years ago
I've been with them over 20 and have had wonderful service. They are very attentive to my insurance needs both business and personal. I highly recommend this company -
Jonathan Rullan ★★★★★ 3 years ago
Craig and the team kicked butt got this done fast and told me all options for me and my Business ! -
A Velez ★★★★★ 4 years ago
Craig was very helpful. Not only getting us the best price but finding better coverage then our old policy offered (And still cheaper). Things we didn't know insurance covered we now have on our policy. Definitely would recommend working … More with Craig from Archdeacon Agency for all insurance needs. -
Dominick V Serra ★★★★★ 4 years ago
I have been incredibly pleased with the level of service and knowledge from Craig and his office. He made the transition from my previous insurance carriers absolutely painless by walking me through each step of the way and expediting the … More … More -
Ryan Jones ★★★★★ 4 years ago
LOVE LOVE LOVE this insurance company!!!! Craig called me to save money on my car insurance and he saved us over $1400.00 from our original policy with them. Everyone who works here are so very helpful, friendly and kind. :-) … More -
Ryan Gerena ★★★★★ 4 years ago
Craig is the man! He helped me get insurance last minute for my business. Very quick, very professional, & genuine! Happy to do business with them! Thanks Craig… More -
Chris Kmieciak ★★★★★ 4 years ago
Craig has been an absolute pleasure to work with from the level of professionalism, timing on the responses and ability to get me a better deal. Highly recommended to work with! -
Ted Turner ★★★★★ 4 years ago
This agency has always done a great job. They go out of the way to get you what you want. Hard to find this level of service anymore. 5 Stars with no hesitations. -
Michele ★★★★★ 4 years ago
Sheri and craig are extremely helpful! I would refer everyone to this agency for excellent service! … More -
Jonathan Orloff ★★★★★ 4 years ago
Very reliable agency, Craig and the employees are fantastic. -
Paul Schiffman ★★★★★ 5 years ago
The Archdeacon Agency has been fulfilling my family's personal and business insurance needs for years. For many years, my father dealt with Donald Archdeacon, the founder, personally and the Archdeacon Agency was always there to give … More my … More -
David Kaufman ★★★★★ 5 years ago
After more than 25 years with another insurance company, I spoke to Craig at Archdeacon and I put my trust (and my wallet) in his hands, and he was just great. I’m now saving $800 and after 6 months, it will get even better! I could not … More … More -
Connie Parisi ★★★★★ 5 years ago
This business is fantastic! I’ve worked with Sheri, Alicia, and Craig and they are all the most professional, kind, and knowledgeable people working in the insurance business. I have a lot of drivers, vehicles, and questions and they never … More … More -
dian Larkin Yudelove ★★★★★ 5 years ago
I've been with the Archdeacon Agency for several years now and would not change agents! I've worked with Sheri, Alycia and Craig and all of them have been wonderful. The immediate response and individual attention they give each … More client is … More -
Sydney Rau ★★★★★ 5 years ago
The best in the business! Hard work and dedication combined with the skills needed to save everyone the most money possible! My whole family has saved hundreds thanks to Archdeacon. My family could not be happier with the quick and reliable … More customer service and the unbeatable quotes. I highly recommend! -
Kelly Lennon ★★★★★ 6 years ago
Sheri is an absolutely pleasure to work with!
Lake Grove, New York Office
2233 Nesconset Hwy, Suite 202
Lake Grove, New York 11755Fax: 631-751-5167
Want to talk?
Let’s do it.
Call our New York office today.






